WHS Prosecution Lawyer Category 1, 2 and 3 Defence in NSW

Charged by SafeWork NSW, or expecting to be? Speak with Eric before the first Court date. Eric defends businesses, directors, officers and individuals in WHS prosecutions across NSW and will represent you in Court.

Phone, video and in-person consultations. Monday to Saturday.

How WHS Prosecutions Work in NSW

Short answer: A WHS prosecution is a criminal proceeding for breaching a duty under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW). Charges are graded as Category 1, 2 or 3 by seriousness. Most are heard summarily in the Industrial Court or Local Court, while industrial manslaughter and Category 1 charges against individuals go to the District or Supreme Court.

If You Have Been Charged

A summons or Court Attendance Notice starts a criminal case. Get advice before the first mention.

  1. Note the first Court date
  2. Identify every defendant and charge
  3. Do not contact witnesses about the case
  4. Speak with Eric about the brief
Call Eric: 0401 937 269

SafeWork NSW prosecutes where there is a reasonable prospect of conviction and it is in the public interest. Its priorities include serious injuries and fatalities, failures to comply with prohibition notices and interference with inspectors.

The prosecution must prove each element of the charge beyond reasonable doubt, including what was reasonably practicable. Many WHS prosecutions turn on technical evidence about the risk, the available controls and what the duty holder knew or ought reasonably to have known.

Judge desk with gavel and scales of justice for a WHS prosecution in NSW

Where This Fits in a SafeWork NSW Matter

Most SafeWork NSW matters move through the same stages. Early advice gives you the most options.

  1. IncidentA death, serious injury or dangerous incident brings SafeWork NSW in.
  2. InvestigationInspectors visit, ask questions and require documents.
  3. NoticesImprovement, prohibition or penalty notices may be issued.
  4. ProsecutionCharges may be laid against the business, its officers or both.You are here
  5. OutcomeA Court outcome, or an enforceable undertaking instead.

The Three Categories of WHS Offence

Category 1 (s 31)

Reckless or grossly negligent conduct that exposes a person to a risk of death or serious injury or illness, without reasonable excuse.

Category 2 (s 32)

Failing to comply with a health and safety duty, where the failure exposes a person to a risk of death or serious injury or illness.

Category 3 (s 33)

Failing to comply with a health and safety duty.

Maximum Penalties for 2026–27

Penalty unit $128.36 from 1 July 2026.

Category 1

  • Company: $11,606,824
  • Officer or sole trader: $2,413,809 or 10 years imprisonment
  • Other individual: $1,160,117 or 10 years imprisonment

Category 2

  • Company: $2,326,910
  • Officer or sole trader: $465,433
  • Other individual: $232,716

Category 3

  • Company: $779,145
  • Officer or sole trader: $155,829
  • Other individual: $77,914

These are maximums. The actual penalty is decided by the Court on the facts and is usually well below the maximum. It is an offence to take out or benefit from insurance that covers a WHS fine (s 272A). Source: SafeWork NSW, Penalties for WHS offences.

Workers in harnesses and helmets working at height on a building, a common focus of WHS prosecutions in NSW

Consequences of a WHS Conviction Beyond the Fine

A WHS prosecution can cost far more than the penalty itself. Depending on the outcome, the consequences can include:

A criminal conviction

A WHS prosecution is a criminal proceeding. A conviction can be recorded against the company, its officers or both, and an individual who is convicted has a criminal record.

Your name made public

SafeWork NSW publishes summaries of prosecutions that end in a conviction, and issues media releases naming companies and directors.

Adverse publicity orders

The Court can order you to publicise the offence and its consequences (s 236), such as a notice in a local newspaper.

Other Court orders

Restoration orders (s 237), WHS project orders (s 238), training orders (s 241) and injunctions (s 240), on top of any fine.

Costs

You may be ordered to pay the prosecutor’s legal costs, on top of the fine and your own legal costs.

No insurance for fines

It is an offence to take out, or benefit from, insurance or an indemnity that covers a WHS fine (s 272A). The business or individual pays.

Directors exposed personally

Officers can be prosecuted separately from the company for failing to exercise due diligence, with their own fines and, for the most serious offences, imprisonment.

Licences suspended or cancelled

SafeWork NSW can suspend or cancel licences such as high-risk work and asbestos licences, including immediate suspension for an imminent serious risk, followed by a disqualification period.

Work stopped

A prohibition notice can stop an activity on the spot until an inspector is satisfied the risk is fixed, causing delays, lost revenue and contract problems.

Penalty notices published

For SafeWork licence holders and White Card holders, paid penalty notices are published for five years from the offence date.

Coronial inquests

A workplace death can be examined by the Coroner, and evidence given at an inquest may later be used in a prosecution.

Reputation and future work

Notices, convictions and publicity can affect tenders, principal contractor approvals, insurers and client relationships.

Sources: Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) ss 27, 236–241, 272A; SafeWork NSW, Prosecutions; SafeWork NSW, Policy for publishing details of WHS penalty notices; SafeWork NSW, Don’t lose your High Risk Work licence; SafeWork NSW media releases.

Courts, Time Limits and Sentencing

Which court?

Most WHS offences are dealt with summarily in the Industrial Court or the Local Court. The Local Court’s maximum fine is 1,200 penalty units. Industrial manslaughter and Category 1 offences by individuals are dealt with on indictment in the District or Supreme Court.

Time limits

Prosecutions must generally be started within two years. Since the 2025 reforms, the Industrial Court can allow a prosecution outside that period if it is in the interests of justice. There is no limitation period for industrial manslaughter.

Who can prosecute

SafeWork NSW, and from 1 March 2026 a registered union for its members if it has consulted SafeWork NSW and SafeWork NSW has declined to prosecute (s 230).

Sentencing orders

As well as fines, the Court can make adverse publicity orders (s 236), restoration orders (s 237), WHS project orders (s 238), court-ordered WHS undertakings (s 239), injunctions (s 240) and training orders (s 241).

Sources: SafeWork NSW Prosecution Guidelines; SafeWork NSW, Prosecutions; Industrial Relations Commission of NSW, Limitation periods; Judicial Commission of NSW, Local Court Bench Book.

How Eric Defends WHS Prosecutions

  1. Review the brief

    Eric examines the charge, the particulars, the alleged duty and the evidence served.

  2. Test each element

    Whether the prosecution can prove the duty, the failure, the risk and what was reasonably practicable.

  3. Advise on options

    Defending the charge, negotiating the charges or particulars, or entering a plea, and what each means for you.

  4. Explore alternatives

    Whether an enforceable undertaking or other outcome may be available instead of a conviction.

  5. Prepare the case

    Expert evidence, witnesses, safety records and evidence of remediation and good character.

  6. Represent you in Court

    From the first mention to a defended hearing or sentence, Eric will represent you in Court.

WHS Prosecution FAQs

What is a Category 1 WHS offence?

Reckless or grossly negligent conduct, without reasonable excuse, that exposes a person to a risk of death or serious injury or illness. For 2026–27 the maximum is $11,606,824 for a company and $2,413,809 or 10 years imprisonment for an officer.

Which court hears WHS prosecutions in NSW?

Most are dealt with summarily in the Industrial Court or Local Court. Industrial manslaughter and Category 1 offences by individuals go to the District or Supreme Court.

How long does SafeWork NSW have to prosecute?

Generally two years, but the Industrial Court can grant leave to prosecute outside that period in the interests of justice. There is no time limit for industrial manslaughter.

Can a company insure against a WHS fine?

No. It is an offence to take out, or benefit from, insurance or an indemnity covering a WHS fine (s 272A).

Can I avoid a conviction for a WHS offence?

In some cases. Outcomes can include a conviction with or without a fine, a court-ordered WHS undertaking, or an enforceable undertaking accepted before or instead of prosecution (not available for Category 1 or industrial manslaughter).

Can Eric represent me in Court?

Yes. Eric is a former Principal Solicitor, Litigation at SafeWork NSW with more than 11 years of court experience, and he represents clients in Court personally.

Latest SafeWork NSW Articles

Practical guides from Eric Navea for NSW businesses, directors and officers dealing with SafeWork NSW.

View all SafeWork NSW articles

Latest articles will load here on the live page.

Facing a SafeWork NSW Investigation or Prosecution?

If SafeWork NSW has contacted your business, issued a notice or served Court documents, speak with Eric before making important decisions.

Eric Navea, SafeWork NSW defence lawyer

Request a Confidential Consultation

    The notice or other documents. PDF, photo or Word, up to 10MB.

    This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It was last reviewed in November 2026. Penalty amounts are indexed each financial year and the law may change. Sources: Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) ss 31–33, 229B, 230, 232, 236–241, 272A; SafeWork NSW Prosecution Guidelines; SafeWork NSW, Prosecutions; SafeWork NSW, Penalties for WHS offences; Industrial Relations Commission of NSW, Limitation periods. Get advice about your specific circumstances.

    Call Eric Send an enquiry